DISCLAIMER: The following article references third-party sources and is intended for general information only, and is NOT intended to provide medical advice or otherwise diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease, including (but not limited to) COVID-19. Consult a qualified physician before beginning any sort of treatment or prophylactic regimen and/or if you know or suspect that you currently have COVID-19. Anyone who takes or does anything mentioned (or alluded to) in this or any other TSAP article does so entirely at their own risk and liability. The TSAP thus makes absolutely no warranties, express or implied, and is not liable for any direct, indirect, special, incidental, consequential, or punitive damages resulting from any act or omission on the part of the reader(s) or others. Caveat lector.
Sunday, August 29, 2021
How To Achieve (Functional) Zero COVID In TWO WEEKS Without Lockdowns, Masks, Or Vaccines (Updated For Delta)
Saturday, August 7, 2021
And So We Learn Just How "Leaky" These Vaccines Really Are
- These vaccines are NOT the silver bullet that so many had hoped for, and putting all of our eggs into that one basket (at the expense of early treatment and prophylaxis like Ivermectin, HCQ, and budesonide, along with various vitamins and other nutrients like Vitamin C, Vitamin D, Niacin, Thiamine, Zinc, Selenium, Quercetin, Resveratrol, NAC, and the amino acid Lysine) was the very height of foolishness at best. Some would even call it mass murder for profit!
- These vaccines are NOT fit for purpose if the goal is to stop all infections, but might still be fit for purpose if the goal is to protect the vulnerable members of society from serious illness and death. And by now, they all have either 1) been vaccinated or 2) chose not to receive it, making that purpose largely academic now in nearly all rich countries, who thus now have a moral duty to freely share these now-abundant vaccines and their patents with poorer countries for all who want it, as there are of course plenty of vulnerable people there too. (As they should have done many months ago, but for corporate greed of Big Pharma.)
- These vaccines are mainly for self-protection, while any protection of the community is at best a bonus. Any argument to the contrary is essentially a specious and spurious argument.
- These vaccines do NOT prevent the evolution or dominance of new virus variants either. Anyone who still thinks so needs their head examined.
- There is ZERO benefit to public health from forcing or coercing people to get these vaccines, restriction of rights for the unvaccinated, and/or segregating the vaccinated and unvaccinated. And there is ZERO justification for such.
- If masks actually worked as source control, there would perhaps be some justification for requiring both vaccinated and unvaccinated people alike to wear them in certain high-risk indoor settings when community spread is at "substantial" or "high" levels, per the CDC.
- But since there is still really no hard evidence that surgical or cloth masks actually work meaningfully as source control at the macro level, even after a year and a half of data, that specious justification also collapses as well. They sure didn't work in 1918, and they don't work now. Rather, we should instead simply recommend (not require) vulnerable adults to correctly wear N95 (or greater) masks, which are now nearly as available and abundant as toothpicks, in such high-risk settings for self-protection. (See a pattern here?)
- When the proverbial fat lady finally sings, it would NOT be because of vaccines, but rather primarily from herd immunity via natural infection, along with perhaps attenuation (weakening) of the virus itself. In other words, just like every other flu or flu-like pandemic and epidemic in recorded history, essentially.
- The Great Barrington Declaration, along with its sister organization PANDA, were therefore quite right all along, by simply following the hard-won wisdom of the ages, and we were very foolish not to listen. We clearly have paid, and will still continue to pay, a very heavy price for our collective foolishness and hubris.
Thursday, July 22, 2021
If Masks Really Worked...
Once again, the witty Professor hits another homerun right out of the park here:
That basically explains the TSAP's evolving position over time. Originally we were pro-mask since we honestly believed they worked based on some spurious observations in a few East Asian and Eastern European countries, plus a few sketchy studies, and thus they seemed like a safe pathway out of lockdown. But as time went on, the evidence just kept on mounting against them. And the past 18 months pretty much answers that question--if they worked, not only would it be so obvious to everyone that no one would have to be forced to wear them, but COVID would have been gone within a few weeks of (near) universal masking as the R value would thus drop well below one and even close to zero, and we would not still be having this debate to this day.
Are you old enough to remember when face masks were initially discouraged by nearly all of the experts as well as "experts", including Dr. Fauci himself? And then, seemingly out of the blue, the idea caught on that masks not only work, but work so well that if 80% (or is that 90%, or 95%, or 99%?) or whatever % of the population were to wear them, COVID would be practically wiped out, or at the very least 100,000+ lives would be saved? Right? And the logical implication being: the sooner everyone would wear them for just a few weeks, the sooner no one would ever have to wear them again, because COVID would be gone!
Well, that didn't really pan out, did it? Look, you can cherry-pick the data all you want, but it's pretty self-evident that masks made no practical or statistical difference overall in terms of COVID case, hospitalization, or death rates, even with the strictest mandates and/or very high compliance above 90% or 95%. While no one can completely rule out modest benefits perhaps in very selected instances, the macro-level data supporting universal masking simply isn't there. Clearly, after 18 months, if a "signal" still cannot be boosted even with great effort, is was most likely just noise all along.
And all that applies a fortiori to children as well, as we have noted previously. There is even less evidence in favor, and even stronger arguments against forcing kids to wear them, especially at this juncture.
Thus, we are re-learning the hard way the painful lessons our ancestors learned in 1918. There was clearly a reason they stopped wearing masks in 1919, after all. And no, it wasn't "selfishness" or "anti-science" sentiment, but a rather a good strong dose of reality that turned even their greatest enthusiasts against them in droves. They simply didn't work.
And now with some "experts" wanting to bring back mask mandates yet again at this stage (!), despite the obvious fact that they would even LESS effective still against the MORE contagious Delta variant, beware. The following Tweet sums it why that is a very bad idea in both theory and practice:
Mask mandates are in fact the THIN end of a very long and thick wedge of coercion. Slopes are indeed much, much slipperier than they appear.
QED
AUGUST UPDATE: Looks like there is even more evidence that masks are basically useless and little more than window dressing overall. That is true even for adults, let alone for children to whom it applies a fortiori to. The pro-mask side of what passes for "debate" really can't rely honestly on science anymore, so they increasingly resort to censorship and ad hominem attacks instead. Ten years from now, if not much sooner, we guarantee that they will regret their stance just like they did not long after 1918.
SEPTEMBER UPDATE: About that poorly-designed Bangladesh study that the pro-maskers are claiming "proves" once and for all that "masks work!", well, it clearly doesn't prove that at all. It also says nothing at all about children, schools, or mandates, since neither of these were studied at all by this study. The best it possibly says is that voluntary use of surgical masks when combined with distancing MIGHT work modestly at the margin in VERY selected instances (even if only a placebo effect as a universal symbol for "keep your distance!"), while cloth masks (i.e. the most commonly used kind) are basically completely useless, and it only goes downhill from there.
Monday, July 19, 2021
Britannia Waives The Rules (Well, Kinda)
Well, it's official now. The UK finally went ahead with Freedom Day today, after a month of delay. Gone are the promises of irreversibility though (i.e. they will not rule out new lockdowns at some point in the future), and some restrictions will still remain though far less than before. But generally speaking, virtually all mandated restrictions have now become downgraded to mere non-binding recommendations for the most part. Better late than never, I guess.
One upside of delaying the final lifting of restrictions to July 19 is that it is being done at or very close to the peak of the current virus surge, so when we most likely see case numbers go down rather than up two weeks or so from now, that will thus thoroughly discredit any belief that these restrictions ever did any good. Had Freedom Day occurred on schedule a month ago on June 23, the case numbers would have been about the same either way regardless of restrictions as we have seen, but people would have no doubt blamed the surge on the lifting of restrictions, then the government would have reimposed restrictions at or close to the peak, after which cases would drop again, and then take credit for the drop, as we have seen many times before. But this time, restrictions are instead being lifted counter-cyclically (i.e. with opposite timing), which will be the real test of their effectiveness and relevance (or lack thereof). Egg meet face, lockdown zealots!
UPDATE: It was announced on literally the same day that, starting in late September, there will be vaccine passports required to enter nightclubs and possibly even sporting events. And it should go without saying that we do NOT support such a thing at all. It is a slippery slope to totalitarianism, plus there is no statistical evidence to back it up.
UPDATE 2: As of July 27th, it is now clear that cases have begun falling rapidly in the UK. And "scientists" are apparently "baffled" by this. They must not remember the famous Farr's Law, or even Hope-Simpson, right? To the lockdown zealots, good luck getting all that egg off of your faces!
UPDATE 3: Looks like Belarus, who practically had NO restrictions all along, really didn't do worse than their neighbors overall in terms of excess all-cause mortality. In case the lockdown zealots didn't have enough egg on their faces already!
AUGUST UPDATE: There has been some head-scratching about why cases started ticking up again in the UK after over two weeks of sharp declines. But this is still no "exit wave" related to lifting restrictions, as it took too long to even begin, is not even a distinct new wave, and has still not topped the previous July high. The best explanation is that the background epidemic has still been rising at the same rate regardless, while in July there was the rapid rise and rapid fall of a sharp and short-term outbreak related to the month-long Euro finals soccer gatherings, mainly in young to middle-aged men. So the lockdown zealots still have egg on their faces to this day. How will they live this one down?
Saturday, July 10, 2021
COVID Is Endemic. "Zero COVID" Is A Pipe Dream. Lockdowns And NPIs Are Useless.
The following Tweet really wins the internet:
Pretty much sums it up. The virus can be defanged and reduced to a nuisance, and indeed it largely has already thanks to herd immunity and attenuation, but it will never be eliminated. It will continue to ebb and flow to one degree or another indefinitely. Even smallpox took over 200 years to eradicate after the vaccine. And it's time we accept that fact and deal with endemic COVID like we do seasonal flu and the common cold. That is, learn to live with the virus just like all other endemic viruses. We know now that lockdowns, masks, social distancing, and stuff like that really make no difference to the course of the virus in the long run, and they come with their own set of problems, ultimately doing more harm than good. And that applies a fortiori to endemic COVID.
That's right, these restrictions are all pain and no gain. And there is a name for doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.
We know how to treat this disease now. We know what to use for prophylaxis as well. We know that the virus, while bad, was never the apocalyptic Big One that some had predicted. We know who the risk groups are, and we have already vaccinated them (plus a good chunk of the general population as well) to a greater extent and faster than we have for any other disease in history. So anyone who says we still somehow can't go 100% back to normal yesterday because reasons is a LIAR with a hidden or not-so-hidden agenda. And we thus must completely disregard their bluster. Yesterday is not soon enough!
UPDATE: Another Tweet, even more to the point:
Friday, June 11, 2021
Britannia Waives The Rules! NOT
It was announced today that the UK's final reopening step in removing the last remaining restrictions, scheduled for June 21st, will most likely be delayed for "up to" (read: at least) another four weeks. The latest excuse is that the supposedly much worse Indian Delta variant of the virus is spreading like wildfire in the UK. Yes, "cases" (i.e. positive tests) are up per the official numbers, but I think we have all seen this movie before, and it's never ended well:
Come on, Boris, stop being such a wee-willy wanker and grow a pair already! What happened to that fun-loving libertarian you once were just 15 months ago? And ask yourself, if the Delta variant is so much more contagious, why isn't it spreading like wildfire in the many other countries in which it has been detected for as long as the UK, including, but not limited to, the USA? Don't think too hard, though--you don't wanna fry the few brain cells you still have left, buddy.
(OK, granted there is Nepal, but they are an outlier.)
Look, practically all of the vulnerable members of society are either 1) fully vaccinated or 2) chose not to get the vaccine. In fact, the UK has one of the highest vaccination rates in the world, as does the USA (who the UK just caught up to recently). Fully 80% of British adults (70% in Scotland) have measurable levels of antibodies, from vaccination, previous infections, or both. If that is not herd immunity, I really don't know what is. Besides, we know the virus is sharply seasonal, and it is now out of season. So the odds of the NHS being overwhelmed this summer are practically zero. Hospitalizations are still largely flat despite the rise in "cases", and though up slightly in some places they are are still nowhere near the first or second wave levels. And deaths are still not budging. Thus, COVID-19 has been reduced to a mere nuisance, and mass testing has created a "casedemic".
Even if there were no vaccines, or for those for whom the vaccine may be a dud, we nonetheless have treatments that work (Ivermectin, Budesonide, etc.). If only the government would allow them, of course.
(Shhhh! Don't be too loud about Niacin and NAC! Now THAT would be the ultimate game-changer! And Vitamin C, D, zinc, and an ionophore like Quercetin.)
We know now that lockdowns and NPIs are worse than useless, and at best you will only push the virus into the fall and winter where when know it is far worse. Thus, a "safe spread summer" is just what the doctor ordered, even if the vaccines were somehow useless against the new variants (which is not true). And masks? Well, maybe chain-link fences are the best defense against mosquitoes, right? Riiiiight.
Meanwhile, the USA is largely full steam ahead with reopening and unmasking, many states already did months ago, and we are doing fine over here. Cases, deaths, and hospitalizations are still falling. Perhaps us "septic tanks" (Yanks) really do have the right idea now after all? I think we all know the answer.
So how about it, Boris? Time to send the SAGE bedwetters packing and open up 100% yesterday!
UPDATE: UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson announced officially that he will be delaying the final reopening step by "four crucial weeks" until July 19th, while leaving open the possibility of delaying it even longer still in the event of a "far more dangerous variant". He dangles the carrot of it possibly being shortened to only a two week delay until July 5th (riiiiight!), and also gives the consolation of the 30 person cap on weddings being lifted on June 21st. But I really wouldn't bet on a full lifting of restrictions anytime soon in Britain, unless of course there are massive and relentless protests along with some very conspicuous civil disobedience there no later than the next week or two. But of course, under the current regime, that would technically be illegal (wink wink).
Oh, and by the way, if you really read between the lines you will see that COVID is actually becoming......milder. That is, it is becoming more cold-like in terms of symptoms and significantly less likely to result in hospitalization or death compared to older strains. And yes, that is the supposedly much worse Delta variant we are talking about, that is now dominant in the UK and will likely eventually become dominant worldwide. As for being somewhat more contagious, that is most likely true, but remember it only needs to be very slightly more contagious to edge out the competition and become dominant, and estimates of it being 60% more contagious than the Alpha strain are most likely grossly exaggerated. In a nutshell, the pandemic is over, attenuation of the virus is occurring along with herd immunity, and endemic COVID is now essentially becoming the new common cold in more and more places, following in the footsteps of the four other endemic common-cold coronaviruses (at least one of which, OC43, most likely started out as a pandemic as well). The fact that this overall good news is being ignored by the mainstream media and government really speaks volumes as to their real agenda of fearmongering, power, and control. Meanwhile, the USA is already several steps ahead of the UK on the road to true normalcy, and in practice is mostly already there now.
Indeed, it seems that the Delta variant's symptoms for most people are practically identical to hay fever and the common cold, with perhaps a mild hangover thrown in for good measure. That is, headache, sore throat, runny nose, and/or generally feeling a little bit "off" are reportedly far more common than the classic fever, cough, loss of smell/taste, or shortness of breath that are common with previous strains of the virus.
UPDATE 2: On June 26th, the March For Freedom had an excellent turnout. And with Matt Hancock resigning in disgrace for his scandalous hypocrisy in flouting his own rules, thus following in the footsteps of the disgraced Neil "Professor Pantsdown" Ferguson, the regime does not seem to be winning anymore.
UPDATE 3: Looks like Delta is already dominant in much of the USA as of July 1, yet overall cases are still not exploding, deaths continue to fall, and hospitalizations remain quite low. Soon it will be dominant worldwide (if it isn't already), but since the best evidence suggests that it is LESS deadly/nasty than previous strains, that is again actually a blessing in disguise on balance. Behold, the soon-to-be new common cold. And you know that Delta is already old news now, as the fearmongers are already talking about the Peruvian Lambda variant now.
Saturday, May 29, 2021
Our Very Last Chance To Let America Be America Again, For Real This Time
It is Memorial Day Weekend, the unofficial start to summer, and COVID-19 is on the run pretty much everywhere now. Cases and deaths are plummeting left and right. All of the most vulnerable members of the American population are either a) fully vaccinated or b) were offered the vaccine but chose not to get it, more than half of the entire population has had at least one vaccine dose, and half of all US adults are now fully vaccinated (i.e. more than two weeks after the final dose). In fact, in ten states and counting, at least 70% of adults (often considered the "herd immunity" threshold in a naive population, ignoring the plentiful natural exposure of at least 30% of Americans already and as much as 50-70% in some states) are now fully vaccinated. And furthermore, we also know now how best to treat this disease as well, even before we had the vaccines.
Is it technically even a pandemic anymore? Depending on one's definition, it may not be.
All states except Hawaii have at least eased (or set a date for easing) their mask mandates, and many have dispensed with them altogether, while nearly all states have reopened their economies and ended most restrictions. The CDC has recently eased recommendations as well. Things are thus largely moving in the right direction for the most part.
Now is thus the time, in fact LONG past time, to end ALL restrictions and go 100% back to normal. And not just for the vaccinated, but for everyone, period. For children as well, in fact a fortiori for them. Masks and social distancing are NOT healthy for children, and fortunately they were generally never at much risk from COVID to begin with. Ignore the bluster from the zealots that want to make these restrictions permanent. No more lockdowns, mask mandates, vaccine passports, or anything like that ever again.
(Another myth bites the dust as well: Not only are kids at a vanishingly low risk of dying or being hospitalized from COVID, they are apparently also highly unlikely to suffer from Long COVID either. Turns out, many if not most of the supposed cases of children under 16 suffering from this vaguely-defined protracted syndrome are likely not even related to the virus at all, given the lack of difference between seronegative and seropositive children in experiencing it. One could thus argue that "lockdown disease" from a toxic mix of prolonged anxiety, isolation, and vitamin deprivation is probably the most parsimonious explanation for most of these cases in both children and adults, even in many cases when the virus is a contributing factor as well. Post-viral syndromes are of course very real, but are generally far more likely to follow severe infections rather than mild ones, and the vast majority of COVID infections are quite mild, especially in children.)
And given how we know that COVID is a very seasonal virus, it would in fact behoove us to allow a "safe spread summer" (i.e. a truly normal summer, kinda like we had in the summer of 1969 despite being during the nasty Hong Kong Flu pandemic, even including Woodstock and literally putting a man on the moon, imagine that!) to build up our immune systems before the fall and winter in case the virus comes roaring back again. Had we done that last summer, we would have had a far less nasty second wave than we did (and third wave in some places as well). And the new variants of the virus if anything make the case for doing so even stronger in fact.
This summer is our LAST CHANCE we have to end the New Abnormal for good and fully restore the civil rights and liberties that we feared were lost forever. If we successfully demand to have a normal summer and resist any attempt to continue or reimpose these authoritarian restrictions in the fall, then the forces of liberty will have won. But if we fail to, well, we only need to look at Germany and the UK to get a glimpse of our dark future going forward. Thus, we must demand a complete return to true normal yesterday, settle for nothing less, and by Labor Day (a day followed by fully open, in-person, un-masked, un-distanced schools starting the very next day) at the latest we must fully resolve to completely lay waste to all that remains of 2020 forever, God willing.
Let America Be America Again. For real this time! And may America finally be reborn on the Fourth of July. So what are we waiting for?
Wednesday, May 26, 2021
And So We Finally Learn Just How Effective Mask Mandates Really Are
Spoiler alert: not very. That is the conclusion of one of the most recent studies, that found--surprise!--no robust correlation between COVID case growth rates and either mask mandates or even mask usage rates across the USA. This dovetails rather nicely with that iconoclastic Danish study from last year, plus literally decades worth of research as well. Look, you can cherry-pick the data all you like to get the results you want, as some previous studies have, but dare to include just enough inconvenient data and the whole house of cards collapses faster than you can say, "A-HA! So THAT'S why Americans universally stopped wearing these things in the spring of 1919, returned to normal, and didn't look back for over 100 years!"
And people will probably keep debating the mask question 100 years from now as well, given how it is one of the oldest debates in public health history. Granted, we do not discount that masks, at least higher quality ones, may very well be at least marginally effective in selected instances. But for the general population across the board, in the realest of real-world settings? Well, if you really believe that, we've got a nice bridge we'd like to sell you.
(And an even bigger bridge to sell those who believe masks were what caused the flu to practically disappear for over a year now. Hey, try to explain how it also practically disappeared in Florida, Georgia, South Dakota, and Sweden then. Go on.)
It's essentially a classic macro-micro problem, where just because something may work at the micro level, it does NOT follow that it will also work at the macro level. The same goes for quarantines, the macro level equivalent of which being indiscriminate, population-wide lockdowns (instead of just the sick). Some things simply don't scale very well at all!
Voluntary mask wearing may simply be a classic placebo, where the wearers may simply be more cautious in general, while forced/coerced mask wearing may lead the wearers to be less cautious in general than they otherwise would, a phenomenon that has also been observed with mandatory seatbelt laws. (To be fair, unlike mask mandates, seatbelt laws do still seem to have a net lifesaving effect regardless, albeit to the chagrin of pedestrians and cyclists.)
Honestly, if they did work at the macro level, then in any place with a broad mask mandate like most states and localities had (or at least mask usage rates above 80%, like practically all of the USA eventually was for a while), the pandemic would have been over within two weeks, three weeks tops. And then masks would have thus made themselves obsolete. Yes, some otherwise highly intelligent and knowledgeable mask advocates actually predicted (over a year ago, no less) that would happen, which in turn influenced even the TSAP's own formerly pro-mask mandate position as an alternative to lockdowns at the time (a position which we now deeply regret). Yet alas, that clearly did NOT happen--for obvious reasons.
And so, once the proper statistical controls (timing, seasonality, previous exposure, etc.) are employed, the statistical mirage of spurious correlation is thus debunked, deboned, sliced, diced, julienned, and its remains have been completely laid waste.
Game. Set. Match.
The TSAP actually supported mask mandates (albeit with nuance) from April/May up until about August 2020, half-supported them until December, and since then we have generally opposed them and currently we support repealing them in their entirety, as was done in 1919 nationwide and has already been done in most states (including those who never had such mandates at all) as of late May 2021. That includes schools too, by the way, especially for students, as even the CDC now subtly admits that school mask mandates for students did NOT show any statistically significant benefit no matter how much they tried to torture the data. (Apparently, the only thing that robustly and reliably works in schools is to ventilate, ventilate, ventilate, which actually makes sense for what we know now is in fact a predominantly airborne virus.) Nor do we support discrimination against anyone by vaccination status either.
Look, if YOU personally want to keep wearing a mask, fine, more power to you. Ditto if you want to avoid people who don't wear them, fine, keep your distance then. Problem solved. But currently we see no valid or compelling reason to continue to force people to wear them, in public or private. Since when did this become such a controversial position to take?
AUGUST UPDATE: Looks like there is even more evidence that masks are basically useless and little more than window dressing overall. That is true even for adults, let alone for children to whom it applies a fortiori to. The pro-mask side of what passes for "debate" really can't rely honestly on science anymore, so they increasingly resort to censorship and ad hominem attacks instead. Ten years from now, if not much sooner, we guarantee that they will regret their stance just like they did not long after 1918.
SEPTEMBER UPDATE: About that poorly-designed Bangladesh study that the pro-maskers are claiming "proves" once and for all that "masks work!", well, it clearly doesn't prove that at all. It also says nothing at all about children, schools, or mandates, since neither of these were studied at all by this study. The best it possibly says is that voluntary use of surgical masks when combined with distancing MIGHT work modestly at the margin in VERY selected instances (even if only a placebo effect as a universal symbol for "keep your distance!"), while cloth masks (i.e. the most commonly used kind) are basically completely useless, and it only goes downhill from there.